LGBTQ-U uses a merit-based scoring system where each entry is judged on its own strengths, rather than directly competing against every other submission. Judges are paid from selection through awards, and the festival does not rely on unpaid volunteer evaluators.
- Top-scoring entries each season receive Best of Festival and Best of Show honors in their categories.
- Best of Festival winners are live screened, while winners down through Excellence can be invited to screen on WRPN.tv.
- Additional levels include Outstanding Excellence, Excellence, Exceptional Merit, Jury’s Choice Award, Merit, and Kudos Endeavor.